Check-up

February 17, 2009

Learning Disabilities

Filed under: Pediatrics, Phase IIA — Tags: , , , , — Jason Booy @ 11:46 pm

Today we talked about Learning Disabilities (LD). The discussion was led by a Kingston Paediatrician who has since risen to the rank of demi-god in my personal reverence! The rest of this post comes directly from him – I have no claim to its originality.

Inattentive Child

What is a learning disability?

 

  • Difficulty reading (dyslexia)
  • Difficulty with written expression (dysgraphia)
  • Difficulty with mathematics (dyscalculia)

 

The following are NOT learning disorders:

 

  • Visual or auditory impairment
  • Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder
  • Emotional disturbance
  • Motor (movement) disability
  • Developmental delay (e.g. down syndrome)

 

Inattentive child

Here was the first eye-opener:

People often say about children with learning disability that they lack motivation, or are uninterested in school work. These children are accused of not producing enough effort. Closer to the truth, however, is that children with learning disability produce enormous effort that fails to yield a positive result. The result is immense frustration, and a decline in motivation since failure is a poor motivator. The chain of causation is crucial to appreciate: children with learning disabilities don’t do poorly because they lack motivation, rather they lack motivation because they do poorly.

inattentive child

Another interesting fact: language-related learning disabilities are more common in English-speaking countries. The most common type of dyslexia is phonetical dyslexia, which is the difficulty or inability to translate letters or words into sounds. In the English language, the same letters and letter-combinations can make a variety of sounds! Take the following (stolen) verse, for example. How confusing for a child with phonetical dyslexia!

When the English tongue we speak
Why is ‘break’ not rhymed with ‘freak’
Will you tell me why it’s true
We say ’sew’ but likewise ‘few’?
And the maker of a verse
Cannot cap his ‘horse’ with ‘worse’
‘Beard’ sounds not the same as ‘heard’,
‘Cord’ is different from ‘word’.
‘Cow’ is ‘cow’, but ‘low’ is ‘low’,
‘Shoe’ is never rhymed with ‘roe’.
Think of ‘hose’ and ‘dose’ and ‘lose’
And think of ‘goose’ and yet of ‘choose’.
Think of ‘comb’ and ‘tomb’ and ‘bomb’
‘Doll’ and ‘roll’, and ‘home’ and ‘come’.
And since ‘pay’ is rhymed with ’say’,
Why not ‘paid’ with ’said’, pray?
We have ‘blood’ and ‘food’ and ‘good’,
‘Mould’ is not pronounced like ‘could’,
Wherefore ‘done’, but ‘gone’ and ‘lone’
Is there any reason known?
And, in short, it seems to me,
Sounds and letters disagree!

-Anonymous 

child writing

Perhaps the most meaningful part of the material we covered this morning, was the library of evidence indicating that school failure is a good predictor for behavioural problems in adolescence, school drop-out, teen pregnancy, drug abuse, and even criminal activity. The convicting realization is that there is considerable opportunity to have a dramatic impact on the course of a child’s life by identifying learning disabilities early, and arranging for adequate accommodation. In nearly all cases, these children just need a little bit of extra, devoted attention to help them overcome the particular difficulty they are having.


5 Comments »

  1. “Think of ‘hose’ and ‘dose’ and ‘lose’”. I was just wondering how closely you read this line… Did you really think of all three? Where did your thoughts go? ;)

    On a more serious side, we talked about school failure => criminal activity in my psych and law class, but there are lots of other factors too!

    Comment by Tim — February 18, 2009 @ 7:13 pm

  2. I love the message this poem conveys.
    Since English is not my first language, I strongly concur that some of the rules made to conceive the English language are arbitrary and contradictory.

    It’s rather frustrating to learn a language whose rules don’t really make sense some of the times. Phonetic patterns are not clear and some of the time, learning them can do more harm than good. Take sew for example… what an annoying word!

    Unfortunately, to learn the English language, you need to do much more than just read numerous books which helps you become exposed to a myriad of words. Normally, this technique would be recommended to become proficient in another language-especially languages in which you pronounce a word exactly as it is written, no silly compound vowels and letters with different sounds to worry about.

    On another note, do you know if children suffering from learning disabilities are more likely to have damaged Broca’s or Wernicke’s areas?

    Comment by D — February 19, 2009 @ 12:41 pm

  3. I really liked the poem, I even felt confused and this silly language is my first language! D’s question about the damage to Broca’s and Wernicke’s area is interesting, I was trying to think if there was anything like that we talked about in Language Development but I couldn’t think of anything so if you find out Jason I would also be interested to know.

    Comment by Sarah — February 20, 2009 @ 12:02 am

  4. You might be interested to learn about new software that can help people with dyslexia.
    Ginger Software (www.gingersoftware.com) has developed groundbreaking text-correction software that automatically corrects spelling mistakes as well as misused words. The software is currently available as a free download from http://www.gingersoftware.com/registration.htm
    The software was designed to support people with learning difficulties and is measured against texts produced by people with dyslexia.
    Later on this year, Ginger will release new version that will include grammar support, text to speech and other supporting features.
    You are welcome to download the software and write your impressions on your blog.

    Regards

    Carmel

    Ginger Software

    Comment by Carmel — March 2, 2009 @ 8:27 am

  5. HAHAHAHA… above comm. made me laugh!

    Comment by D — March 2, 2009 @ 9:24 am


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Blog at WordPress.com.